Showing posts with label the-serious-dept.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the-serious-dept.. Show all posts

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Thoughts on education and civics, part 4

Here's the fourth installment of the series I began in my post on March 2, and have continued here and here. As previously, it should be read as a continuation of the same overall essay. Comments welcome, of course.

We must, then, consider the possibility that it is the government which is (or at least should be) both competent and empowered to distribute educational resources to students in ways which maximize the good of the society. Such, for example, might be a system of 'tracking', in which, responsive to performance on standardized tests, students are assigned to sequences of courses designed to match and strengthen their aptitudes as demonstrated on said tests. Thus, in principle, students whose natural proclivities and skill sets are generally well suited to successful, productive, and satisfying engagement in, say, the legal profession will receive an educational experience tailored to this specific set of characteristics, and will be spared the wasted time and frustration of struggling through irrelevant classes. The government will be spared the wasted expense, supplying exactly the right education to the students who will most benefit from it, without paying for future artists to take trigonometry or future physicians to take computer-aided drafting. Students will, at a younger age, experience the camaraderie of like-minded and -talented peers, benefiting from cooperation and competition with fellows who are striving for similar goals and whose interests coincide closely with their own. Such homogeneous grouping will also allow for inculcation of a sense of the value of the particular vocation or pursuit particular to the group. Thus, the apparent second option, its features and consequences.

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Thoughts on education and civics, part 3

Here's the third installment of the series I began in my post on March 2, and continued on March 14. It should be read as a continuation of the same overall essay.


And so, we posit that the government is obliged to provide an education which is responsive to the various diversities of its population. Let us ignore, for the sake of argument, the very real pragmatic problems one might raise here (paying for such a program, for instance). Even assuming that a civil government is fully able to fund and staff such a system of education, nothing can come of it until a central question is answered: who is empowered, and competent, to decide which students receive which education, among they myriad possibilities? Society as a whole (in practical terms, this means the representatives of the government), or individuals? Our intuitive, reflexive response is toward the latter: only parents, teachers, and the students themselves have the relevant knowledge to make appropriate choices for individual students' education. But by appealing to such justification, we have surreptitiously changed our goals and our point of view. Up to now, recall, we have been constructing our hypothetical educational system based on considering the needs of civil society, not of individuals. Parents and students may indeed be the most competent judges of what education is best for individual students. But are they at all competent to determine the needs of society as a whole? Does any given parent, teacher or student have the necessary knowledge, insight, or objectivity to recognize, analyze, predict, and privilege the elements required to provide society with the maximal pool of civically prepared citizens? Perhaps. Yet even if we grant it so, this conclusion rests on the prima facie unrealistic assumption that, in the immortal words, 'the good of the many' and 'the good of the few, or the one' will align. It is far too clear to anyone who has even a cursory knowledge of humanity that this assumption is unworkable.

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Thoughts on education and civics, part 2

Here's the next installment of the series I began in my post on March 2. It should be read as a continuation of the same overall essay.


Any analysis of public education automatically starts with a fundamental tension. For although the ideal goals of the liberal tradition rest on education as the betterment of the individual human being, a government brings its own ulterior motives as a condition for providing such education. The ultimate goal of public education must be the cultivation of educated individuals qua citizens, and not qua individuals. But what practical siginificance does this have? Is this distinction not a matter of hair-splitting, after all? Why can't a government provide an education which, in fact, meets the requirements of both a liberal education and, as it were, 'collectivist' civic training? On an individual or case-by-case particular basis, it does seem obvious that liberal and civic education are far from incompatible.

The full answer to the above objection, however, forces us to think beyond the individual case. Civil government is responsible for the education of 'the youth', that is, the sum total (or as near as is practical) of all its citizens' offspring, regardless of social, intellectual, cultural, or any other feature or ability. We are comfortable admitting this; nay more, we celebrate it (and rightly so) as morally right. Less frequently, and less comfortably, do we ask the natural subsequent question: how should civil government appropriately match students' abilities and educational pursuits? As we have already granted, it is in the government's interest to maximize the capacity of its citizenship for informed participation in the vital functions of democracy; and it is surely unrealistic to suppose, given the significant and multifaceted diversity of our society, that a one-size-fits-all educational program would be anywhere near adequate to provide even an approximation of a generally informed electorate. (At least, this last consequence follows readily given our contemporary commitment to the pragmatic significance of diversity. Should this commitment be reconsidered, the conclusions dependent upon it would of course bear similar rethinking.)

Monday, March 2, 2009

Thoughts on education and civics

What appears below may or may not be the beginning of a series of mini-essays ruminating on the nature of education - in theory, in practice, and in relation to the existence of a civilization. Make of it what you will.

It’s a truism, I think, to say that an individual’s education – his upbringing, background, the axioms of his fundamental beliefs, his knowledge of history (both the history of persons and events and the history of ideas), his awareness of the accidental facts of the world and culture he inhabits – inescapably influences, if not directs, the development of the sort of person he makes himself. A fortiori, education exercises the same degree of influence on the development of the sort of citizen an individual becomes. This very basic, yet fundamental, recognition of the relation between education and citizenship is among the central starting points of the political theory and thought behind the United States as an entity. One of the primary reasons providing public education has been seen historically as a quintessentially appropriate function of the American federal government is that, since the type of education one receives goes far to determine one’s capacity to shoulder one’s responsibilities of civic participation, and since a democracy requires its citizens to maintain such participation, it is not only in a democracy’s best interests to provide education to its citizens, but it is also an obligation.

Thus far, I’ve not stated anything at all new (although it is important that even the most evident truths be periodically revisited and restated in public dialogue, in order to prevent them from being lost by attrition over the generations). However, to say that government is obliged to provide education to its citizens is to make a claim so broad as to be useless. (Compare the Nicomachean Ethics, where Aristotle reminds us that everyone agrees that happiness is the end of the good life – but it is precisely in determining what constitutes happiness where people diverge widely.) Similarly, we must first pose the question: What kind of education is the government obliged to provide? Not only must we pose this question, but we must answer it, and provide an answer which is directly applicable in policy and in practice.